Mysterious Finds LLC

(856) 813-9131

Follow company

Sports Collectibles, Records, cards and more

Follow sale Following sale

Delivery Shipping & In-person

Sort by: Ending Soonest

Lot 1
1997-99 Starting Lineup Sammy Sosa, Sam Snead, & Hideki Irabu

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 2
Headliners XL Sammy Sosa with Display Case

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 3
1997 Starting Lineup Cal Ripken Jr/ Ken Griffey Jr & Hallmark Ornam...

Bid
$5.00 1 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 4
1998 Starting Lineup Jaromir Jagr, Dominik Hasek, Wayne Gretzky

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 5
1999 Headliners XL Limited Edition Ken Griffey Jr

Bid
$5.00 1 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 6
1997/98 Starting Lineup Tony Esposito, Maurice Richard, Mike Eruzione

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 7
Home Run Headliners XL Mark McGwire, Ken Griffey Jr

Bid
$5.00 1 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 8
1997/98 Headliners NHL Superstars, Gretzky, Messier, Lemieux, Hull,...

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 9
Headliners XL Mark McGwire with Display Case

Bid
$5.00 1 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 10
1998 Freeze Frame One on One Starting Lineup Gretzky Vs Bure

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 11
NBA Super Stars 13" Tim Duncan

Bid
$5.00 1 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 12
1997/98 Headliners Toni Kukoc, Luc Longley, Martin Brodeur

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 13
1998 Freeze Frame Starting Lineup Wayne Gretzky

Bid
$5.00 1 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 14
NBA Super Stars Then & Now Collection Michael Jordan

Bid
$9.00 5 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 15
Sports Illustrated Collection Pewter Figure Mickey Mantle

Bid
$5.00 1 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 16
1997 Starting Lineup Kevin Garnett, John Stockton, Peter Forsberg

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 17
Gridiron Greats Starting Lineup Emmett Smith

Bid
$5.00 1 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 18
1996/2000-2001 Starting Lineup Robinson, Kamenshek, Bourque

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 19
1997 Starting Lineup Legends Montana, Dawson, Namath, Theismann

Bid
$5.00 1 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 20
1998 Stadium Stars Ivan Rodriquez

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 21
1997 Headliners Rodman, Hardaway, Hill, Miller, Ewing, Kukoc, Pippe...

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 22
Sports Illustrated Collection Pewter Figure Ken Griffey Jr

Bid
$5.00 1 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 23
1996/97 Hallmark Sport Ornaments Johnson, Gretzky, KC, SF

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 24
1976 Topps Steelers Various Players

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 25
2011 Prestige Pros Including Cedric Benson # 76/100, & Rookie Cards...

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 26
1997 Hallmark Wayne Gretzky

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 27
2005-2007 Upper Deck, Press Pass Rookie & Rookie Debut

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 28
2005-06 BCCG Upper Deck Phenomenal Beginnings #11 Sidney Crosby 10 ...

Bid
$20.00 1 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 29
2003, 2005-06 BCCG Photo Cards Nadal & Phenomenal Beginnings Gold C...

Bid
$30.00 1 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 30
1999 Brian Griese, 2011 Matt Schaub #26/249, Greg Jennings, Boomer ...

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 31
2006 Playoff Prestige Rookies & 2010 Pat Paschall #24/250, Blair Wh...

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 32
2002, 2007 PressPass David Carr, Seluin Young & Adrian Peterson

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 33
2009-2012 Score, Donruss Jeremy Kerley #324/499

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 34
2009 Authentic Autograph Boldin, Sintim, Simmons, McBath

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 35
2001-2011 Topps Chrome Peterson, Kaepernick

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 36
2000 PressPass, 2010 Prestige, 1995 Score, 2011 Donruss

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 37
1982 Topps Signed Harold Jackson, 2002 PressPass Levi Jones, 1996 J...

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 38
2003 PSA Topps Carson Palmer #311 Gem Mint 10 & 2006 PSA Score Lein...

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 39
1962 Topps Orioles, White Sox, Braves

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 40
1962 Topps Cardinals, Angels, Phillies

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 41
1962 Topps Dodgers, Giants, Cubs

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 42
1996 Absolute Playoff Cards With Binder

Bid
$10.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 43
LeBron James Photo & Collectable Tin and Watch

Bid
$7.00 3 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 44
1984 Jordan Experience, 1991-1997 Bulls Championship Pins, 1996 Den...

Bid
$12.00 5 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 45
2008 President Obama Election Book, Pin, Cards

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 46
1992 Olympic Challenge Tabacco Style Cards, Olympic Tee Shirts

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 47
1961-1997 Princess Diana Franklin Mint & Bradford Exchange Tribute ...

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 48
1961-1997 Princess Diana Franklin Mint & Danbury Mint Future King T...

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 49
1961-1997 Princess Diana Franklin Mint & Bradford Exchange "England...

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 50
Mike Ploog Stickers

Bid
$20.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 51
1994 Lee MacLeod Sci-Fi Fantasy Art Trading Card Collection

Bid
$20.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 52
Bernie Wrightson Stickers

Bid
$20.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 53
Starting Lineup Sam Snead, Arnold Palmer, Jim Thorpe, Bruce Jenner

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 54
The Olympic Games Patch Collection

Bid
$150.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 55
Cal Ripken Jr & Ted Williams Porcelain Card Collection

Bid
$40.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 56
Empty Baseball Player Cans Rolan, Clemens, Grieve, Jones, Jeter, Ma...

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 57
Ted Williams Binder, Cal Ripken Jr Premier Replays, 23KT Gold Card,...

Bid
$5.00 1 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 58
Famous People Tobacco Style Cards

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 59
1992 Ultimate Trading Card Company Bobby Hull

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 60
2009 Upper Deck Collectors Choice

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 61
2001, 2008 Topps Barack Obama Cards

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 62
2009 Topps Heritage American Heroes Edition

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 63
1992 Ultimate Trading Card Company Henri Richard, Bobby Hull, 1994 ...

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 64
1993 Classic Four Sport Collection

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 65
2001 Upper Deck PGA Tour

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 66
2009 Upper Deck Collectors Choice

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 67
1991 Beckett All World Boxing 2 Ali #1 & Bonus Card #3 10 Mint or B...

Bid
$15.00 1 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 68
1991 Beckett All World 2 Ali Bonus Card #2 10 Mint or Better & Hall...

Bid
$15.00 1 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 69
1991 Beckett All World Boxing 2 Ali #1 & Bonus Card #3 10 Mint or B...

Bid
$15.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 70
1998 23KT Gold Card Starting Five, 2000 Michael Jordan Sports Sound...

Bid
$5.00 1 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 71
1996 Hallmark Magic Johnson, Beckett 2003-04 #224 Chris Bosh 10 Min...

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 72
1991 Kenny Smith, Otis Thorpe & 1996 Upper Deck USA Basketball Olym...

Bid
$6.00 2 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 73
2001 Upper Deck Tiger's Tales

Bid
$9.00 4 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 74
1995 Pro Line Various Players

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 75
1990 The All Madden Team

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 76
2006 Score Various Players

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 77
1995 Black Label

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 78
1997 Upper Deck

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 79
1997 Playoffs

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 80
1996 Pro Line

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 81
1997 Topps Various Players

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 82
Ted Williams Baseball & Cal Ripken Jr Baseball & Bat

Bid
$10.00 6 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 83
Cal Ripken Jr Autographed End of Streak Plaque

Bid
$150.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 84
1990-92 Gretzky, "Rocket", Lemieux & 2009 Stanley Champions Pin/Hoc...

Bid
$5.00 1 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 85
Philadelphia Eagles Bronze Medallion, 1997 Hallmark Namath Ornament...

Bid
$5.00 1 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 86
The Beatles & Jerry Lee Lewis 45's

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 87
The Beatles & Archie Bell & The Drells 45's

Bid
$5.00 1 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 88
DeathWatch 2000, 1989 Dick Lane Art Series, & 2001 Beckett The Rook...

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 89
2001 Topps American Pie, Legends of Rock 'N Roll Lithograph, & Hist...

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 90
1996 Upper Deck USA Olympicard "Passing the Torch" & 2004 Fleer Nat...

Bid
$20.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 91
Signed Redskins Jersey "Arrington" & Stadium Fan Cushion from Fan D...

Bid
$100.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 92
Star Wars Trilogy Special Edition VHS

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 93
LFP Tribute to Diana Princess of Wales & Guide Books

Bid
$5.00 1 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 94
Bedtime Story Book & Bible

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 95
2006 Fleer Base Set Plus Extras

Bid
$5.00 1 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 96
2006 Fleer Base Set With Extras

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 97
2006 Fleer Base Set With Extras

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 98
2006 Fleer Base Set With Extras

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 99
2006 Fleer Base Set With Extras

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow
Lot 100
2006 Fleer Base Set With Extras

Bid
$5.00 0 bids

Shipping Available

Newfield, NJ

loading...

Follow

Next 100 Items

Items 1 - 100 of 117

Per page: